City Court of Westchester · Index No. 67359/2023 · Robert S. Ondrovic, J.
N.D. and J.R. v Green A.B. Housing Authority
Mark Alan Siesel, Attorneys for Plaintiff
The Towne Law Firm, P.C., Attorneys for Defendant
The following papers were considered on the motion:
| Papers | Numbered |
|---|---|
| Notice of Motion, Affirmation, Exhibits A — S, Memo of Law, Statement of Material Facts | 1 — 23 |
| Affirmation in Opposition, Exhibits 1 — 10, Response to Statement of Material Facts | 24 — 35 |
| Reply Memo of Law | 36 |
In an action to recover damages for personal injuries, the defendant moves pursuant to CPLR § 3212 for summary judgment dismissing the complaint.
Relevant Factual and Procedural Background
On July 3, 2022, the plaintiffs N.D. and J.R. (hereinafter together the plaintiffs), were assaulted by TY.P. and TN.P. (hereinafter together The P.s). The assault took place at Glenville Gardens, a public housing development owned and operated by the defendant Green A.B. Housing Authority (hereinafter GHA). The plaintiffs and The P.s are residents of Glenville Gardens. In September 2023, the plaintiffs commenced this action against GHA asserting causes of action sounding in negligence and premises liability.
N.D., J.R. (N.D.'s aunt), and C.D. (N.D.'s mother and J.R.'s sister), testified, in relevant part, at a hearing pursuant to General Municipal Law § 50-h and deposition as follows:
In July 2022, N.D. was residing with J.R. and her grandmother, A.B., at A.B.'s home on GHA property. The P.s also resided on GHA property in an apartment close to A.B.'s home. N.D. testified that approximately six to nine months prior to the subject incident, The P.s, along with T.D. and B.H., began harassing her at school and sending her threatening messages via text and Snapchat.FN1 They bumped into her in the hallways and made gagging noises. N.D. reported those incidents to the school. N.D. also experienced harassment by The P.s when leaving her home. On about four or five occasions, The P.s would yell at her "that they are going to beat [her], or they are going to catch [her] or see [her]."FN2 She did not report those incidents to GHA.
In March 2022, N.D. and C.D. met with Ebony G., B.H.'s mother, and TA.D., T.D.'s mother and a GHA employee, to discuss the ongoing harassment. The meeting was not planned; C.D. and N.D. just "went over there."FN3 During the meeting, T.D. expressed that "this is nonsense high school stuff" and "they should all move past it."FN4 C.D. did not ask T.D. to report the harassment to GHA. C.D. testified that the meeting was supposed to be only with Ebony, and she did not know whether T.D. joined the meeting as a person who works for GHA or because T.D. was involved. Immediately after leaving that meeting, N.D. received text messages from TN.P. threatening physical harm. N.D. met TN.P. outside and a physical altercation ensued in the parking lot on GHA property. N.D. and C.D. reported the incident to the police. C.D. testified that she sent an email to GHA employees Raju Abraham and Marcus Davis regarding the March 2022 altercation.
The P.s continued to harass, bully, and intimidate N.D. at school. N.D. did not file a written report with GHA or go into any GHA office to report what was happening. A.B. testified at a deposition that between March 2022 and July 2022, she called the GHA office and spoke to either Raju Abraham or Marcus Davis about the situation.
On July 3, at approximately 8 p.m., N.D., J.R., and A.B. went to The P.s's home to speak with their parents. At some point, TN.P. charged at N.D. and began punching, kicking, and pulling her hair. N.D. was struck with a baseball bat on her left arm and right knee. The P.s also attacked J.R. Trinity struck J.R. with the bat on her left thigh and left arm. A.B. called the police and N.D. and J.R. were transported by ambulance to the hospital. No one from GHA was present during the altercation. C.D. reported the incident to the police. The incident was filmed by T.D., who posted the video on social media.
C.D. reported the incident to GHA by sending an email to Raju Abraham and Marcus Davis. N.D. testified that between March 2022 and July 2022, no other incidents occurred between her and The P.s on GHA property, but The P.s continued harassing and threatening her at school. J.R. testified that at some point prior to the subject incident, she had a conversation with T.D. at T.D.'s home about N.D. being bullied at school by T.D., The P.s, and Brianna. A.B. testified that in around May 2022, she went to T.D.'s home and told her that T.D. was harassing N.D. and that N.D. could not leave the house without T.D. yelling for others to come outside to fight N.D.
Marcus Davis testified at a deposition that he is employed by GHA and his title is resident relations. He stated that T.D. is employed by GHA as a Section 8 assistant. Davis testified that Raju Abraham is responsible for overseeing all aspects of GHA. He stated that if a tenant wanted to report an incident to him, he could be reached by email or telephone, or in person at the GHA office in White Plains. Davis testified that prior to the incident on July 3, 2022, he had no knowledge that N.D. was being harassed by GHA tenants or that TN.P. had physically assaulted N.D. in March 2022. He acknowledged that The P.s still reside on GHA property, he took no action after reviewing a video recording of the incident and took no steps to evict The P.s from their home. Davis stated that he never spoke with T.D. about N.D. being harassed or the March 2022 meeting between T.D. and other GHA tenants. When asked about the presence of security, Davis stated that GHA employs two watchmen who patrol seven different sites, and after the incident, they were asked to increase their presence at the subject property. He claimed that A.B. never complained to him about lack of security or emailed him about The P.s.
Raju Abraham testified at a deposition that he is employed by GHA as executive director and his responsibilities include planning, coordinating, and managing all GHA projects. He acknowledged that he is responsible for ensuring tenant safety. Abraham stated that he began working for GHA in 1999 as a senior bookkeeper. He testified that T.D. is employed by GHA as an intermediate clerk with "broad" responsibilities, including "[s]leeve filing, intake, meeting with tenants, simple calculations."FN5 Abraham acknowledged that GHA has a "one strike and you're out" policy and that the leases provide, among other things, that residents shall not permit "household members or guests to act in a manner that will disturb the rights or comfort of neighbors" or "engage in any criminal activity that threatens the health, safety, and right to peaceful enjoyment of the premises."FN6 He stated that GHA employs two watch persons who patrol five different properties. Abraham did not recall receiving any emails from A.B. or C.D. regarding The P.s before July 2022. He testified that he was unaware that criminal charges had been filed against The P.s as a result of the incident; that T.D.'s daughter recorded the incident; or that bats were used by The P.s during the incident. Abraham stated that he did not see the video until his deposition and had never spoken with N.D., A.B., or J.R. about the incident. He confirmed that The P.s still reside on GHA property.
TA.D. testified at a deposition that she is employed by GHA as a clerk in the Section 8 department and her responsibilities include answering phones and rent calculations. She stated that she is not involved in security issues. T.D. testified that she has resided on the subject property since 2010. She stated that she was aware of "bickering" between The P.s and N.D., but unaware of threats, bullying, or harassing.FN7 T.D. testified that it is not her responsibility to "know what is going on with the tenants" or "to notify someone at [GHA] that there was harassment and bulling of N.D. going on by The P.s."FN8 She stated that when she is at home, she is a resident, not an employee. T.D. testified that she was unaware that T.D. had filmed the incident and had not watched the video until her deposition.
According to T.D., prior to the subject incident, C.D. and "her mob of people" came to Ebony's house "to fight," but Ebony and T.D. invited C.D. inside to "have a civil conversation to get to the bottom of what was going on between [their] daughters."FN9 T.D. believed the issues had been resolved that day and had no further discussions with C.D. or A.B. She testified that she did not notify Davis or Abraham about the meeting because it is "not a part of [her] job when [she is] home as a tenant."FN10 She stated that she did not discuss the subject incident with Davis or Abraham or inform them that The P.s had used bats. She testified that she was never contacted by the school about T.D.'s involvement in bullying N.D.
GHA's Motion
After discovery was completed, GHA moved for summary judgment dismissing the complaint. In a supporting affirmation and memorandum of law, GHA argued that the plaintiffs seek to hold it liable to failing to prevent the independent criminal acts of third parties over whom it exercised no supervision or control. It emphasized that the incident arose out of personal dispute among young individuals "whose conflict originated through school-related interactions, social media communications, and personal relationships independent of GHA's role as landlord."FN11 GHA argued that there is no evidence demonstrating that GHA had any knowledge of circumstances suggesting a violent assault was imminent. GHA also argued that any knowledge acquired by T.D. cannot be imputed to GHA where her knowledge arose from a personal interaction with her daughter, and not through the performance of her employment.
In opposition, the plaintiffs argued that pursuant to the terms of the GHA lease agreement "and other property rules," GHA voluntarily assumed a duty to protect the plaintiffs from the independent criminal acts of The P.s.FN12 The plaintiffs asserted that GHA employees Raju Abraham and TA.D. were aware of The P.s' dangerous behavior two years before the July 2022 incident and failed to take reasonable steps to protect them from foreseeable harm. The plaintiffs also asserted that triable issue of fact existed regarding whether T.D.'s knowledge of the history between N.D. and The P.s was sufficient to establish that the harm complained of was foreseeable to GHA.
In reply, GHA argued that the "one strike" policy does not create a duty to prevent one tenant from attacking another tenant unless it has the authority to control the conduct of the assailant. It also contended that the ability to control a third person does not arise from the power to evict. GHA reiterated that even if a duty existed, the July 3, 2022 was not foreseeable. It noted that there was only one altercation in March 2022 on GHA property involving N.D. and TN.P., most of the harassment and threats happened at school or on social media, and neither Abraham nor Davis were aware that N.D. was being harassed or threatened by The P.s.
Analysis
"'A landlord has no duty to prevent one tenant from attacking another tenant unless it has the authority, ability, and opportunity to control the actions of the assailant'" (Mills v Gardner, 106 AD3d 885, 886 [2d Dept 2013], quoting Britt v New York City Hous. Auth., 3 AD3d 514, 514 [2d Dept 2004]; see Adelstein v Waterview Towers, Inc., 250 AD2d 790, 791 [2d Dept 1998]; Firpi v New York City Hous. Auth., 175 AD2d 858, 859 [2d Dept 1991]).
GHA demonstrated, prima facie, that it lacked the authority, ability, and opportunity to control The P.s' conduct (see Virella v 245 North Street Housing Dev. Fund Corp., 188 AD3d 1618, 1620 [4th Dept 2020]; Adelstein v Waterview Towers, Inc., 250 AD2d 790, 791 [2d Dept 1998]; Hughes v City of New York, 238 AD2d 477 [2d Dept 1997]; Siino v Reices, 216 AD2d 552, 553 [2d Dept 1995]). The plaintiffs insist that pursuant to GHA's "one strike and you're out" policy, code of behavior, and other provisions in the lease agreement, GHA assumed a duty to protect the plaintiffs from The P.s. Although those provisions authorize GHA to institute eviction proceedings when, among other reasons, a tenant fails to comply with the rules governing tenant conduct, it is well settled that "[a] reasonable opportunity or effective means to control a third person does not arise from the mere power to evict" (Siino v Reices, 216 AD2d 552, 553 [2d Dept 1995]; see Rodriguez v Madison Security Group, Inc., 247 AD3d 672 [1st Dept 2026]; Britt v New York City Hous. Auth., 3 AD3d 514 [2d Dept 2004]; Blatt v New York City Hous. Auth., 123 AD2d 591, 592 [2d Dept 1996]). Nor can it be said, under the circumstances of this case, that GHA assumed a special duty to protect the plaintiffs from The P.s (see Blatt v New York City Hous. Auth., 123 AD2d 591, 592 [2d Dept 1996]).
In Blatt, the plaintiff, a resident of the defendant New York City Housing Authority (hereinafter the NYCHA), was shot by another resident in the lobby of the building. One month prior to the incident, the assailant threatened the plaintiff with a gun and the plaintiff reported the threat to the NYCHA soon thereafter. The Second Department held that the plaintiff failed to demonstrate the existence of a duty owed to him by the NYCHA, emphasizing "[t]he power to evict cannot be said to have furnished the NYCHA with a 'reasonable opportunity or effective means' to prevent or remedy [that tenant's] unacceptable conduct, since the incident giving rise to the injuries sustained, and indeed the 'pattern' of harassment alleged by the plaintiff, arose from a purely personal dispute between two individuals" (123 AD2d at 593).
GHA also demonstrated, prima facie, that it lacked notice of any foreseeable threat that The P.s would attack the plaintiffs on GHA property, notwithstanding the alleged ongoing harassment and threats, the vast majority of which occurred at school or through social media and text messages (see Virella v 245 North Street Housing Dev. Fund Corp., 188 AD3d 1618, 1620 [4th Dept 2020] [landlord's awareness of possible harassment of tenant by other tenant failed to demonstrate assault was foreseeable]; Bonano v XYZ Corp., 261 AD2d 280 [1st Dept 1999] [same]; Johnson v Slocum Realty Corp., 191 AD2d 613, 615 [2d Dept 1993] [tenant failed to establish existence of a duty owed to him by landlord where landlord lacked knowledge that BB gun was being fired on premises by other tenant]; Firpi v New York City Hous. Auth., 175 AD2d 858, 859 [2d Dept 1991] [although tenant had history of being a "harassing troublemaker," there was no evidence that housing authority had notice of foreseeable threat that tenant would attack plaintiff in building lobby]).
Here, GHA employees Davis and Abraham both testified that they had no prior knowledge that N.D. was being harassed by any GHA tenants. Davis testified that he was unaware that TN.P. had physically assaulted N.D. in March 2022 and never spoke with T.D. about N.D. being harassed or her meeting in March 2022 with N.D. and C.D. T.D. testified that she did not notify Davis or Abraham about the March 2022 meeting since it was unrelated to her job. C.D.'s testimony that the March 2022 meeting was supposed to be only with Ebony; she did not ask T.D. to be present; and T.D. "just happened to show up," suggests that T.D. was not present in an official capacity.FN13 C.D. acknowledged that she did not ask T.D. to report the harassing social media messages to GHA.
T.D. testified that other than the March 2022 meeting, she had no further discussions with C.D. or A.B. regarding the situation. J.R. that at some point prior to the July 2022 incident, she had a conversation with T.D. at T.D.'s home about N.D. being bullied at school by T.D., The P.s, and Brianna. A.B. testified that in around May 2022, she went to T.D.'s home and told her that T.D. was harassing N.D. and that N.D. could not leave the house without T.D. yelling for others to come outside to fight N.D.
While the evidence demonstrates that many incidents involving The P.s and N.D. were reported to their school, the plaintiffs failed to identify any specific complaints made directly to GHA about The P.s being violent or making explicit threats of violence to N.D. N.D. acknowledged that she did not report to GHA the four or five occasions when The P.s threatened to attack her while on GHA property. She also acknowledged that despite The P.s's continued harassment and intimidation at school, she did not file a written report with GHA or go into any GHA office to report what was happening. According to N.D., no other incidents occurred between her and The P.s on GHA property between March 2022 and July 2022. There is no evidence substantiating C.D.'s testimony that she sent an email to Abraham and Davis regarding the March 2022 altercation between N.D. and TN.P. or that a copy of the resulting police report was forwarded to GHA. A.B. testified that between March 2022 and July 2022, she called the GHA office and spoke to either Raju Abraham or Marcus Davis about The P.s's conduct. Even accepting the testimony of N.D., J.R., C.D., and A.B. as true, the Court agrees with GHA that the evidence is insufficient to raise a triable issue of fact as to whether the July 3, 2022 assault on GHA property was foreseeable (see Virella v 245 North Street Housing Dev. Fund Corp., 188 AD3d 1618 [4th Dept 2020]; Britt v New York City Hous. Auth., 3 AD3d 514 [2d Dept 2004]; Johnson v Slocum Realty Corp., 191 AD2d 613, 615 [2d Dept 1993]).
In Firpi v New York City Housing Authority, (175 AD2d 858 [2d Dept 1991]), the plaintiff, a resident of the NYCHA, was attacked by another resident with whom he had a history of disputes. The Second Department held that "[w]hile [the resident] may have had a history as a harassing troublemaker, there is no evidence in the record that the [NYCHA] had notice of any foreseeable threat that [the resident] would attack [the plaintiff] with a knife in the lobby of their building" (id. at 859).
In opposition, the plaintiffs failed to raise a triable issue of fact. Contrary to the plaintiffs' contention, any personal knowledge acquired by T.D. regarding The P.s's history of harassment and intimidation of N.D. cannot, under the circumstances, be imputed to GHA (see Chritopher S. v Douglaston Club, 275 AD2d 768, 770-771 [2d Dept 2000] [board members' awareness of assailant's history of improper sexual behavior cannot be imputed to defendant since knowledge was attained as fathers of sons involved in prior incident and not as agents of defendant]).
Accordingly, it is hereby,
ORDERED that the defendant's motion for summary judgment dismissing the complaint is granted; and it is further,
ORDERED that all other relief requested and not decided herein is denied.
The foregoing constitutes the Decision and Order of this Court.
White Plains, NY
ENTER
HON. ROBERT S. ONDROVIC, J.S.C.